That is an opinion piece from my private perspective. A few of you could know that I’ve a second facet hustle. In addition to working this weblog, I additionally make jewelry and am an Etsy vendor.
I’m feeling more and more pissed off on the growing variety of my friends who’re having their designs stolen and their pictures blatantly utilized by Chinese language producers and but can’t do something about it.
It’s not proper and it sucks and this weblog submit has completely nothing to do with tenting, however this can be a matter that issues to me, so listed here are my ideas on the likes of Temu and rampant ‘dupe’ tradition as seen on TikTok.
Over the previous couple of months, it’s been unattainable to flee the newest market for reasonable items from China, Temu.
With a advertising and marketing funds of what should be many thousands and thousands and a method that sees them doing something they’ll, together with working at a loss in an effort to acquire market share, Temu has come to dominate Google search and procuring outcomes for all the pieces from craft provides to clothes.
Identical to Shein, Want, AliExpress and others, the brand new child on the block sells something and all the pieces direct from producers and is aggressively marketed all around the web and TV streaming providers.
Aside from the plain ecological issues associated to overproduction, waste and transportation in addition to the intensive claims of compelled and little one labour, there’s one other reality that folks appear completely pleased to disregard.
It’s well-known by these of us who draw, design and create for a residing, that web sites like Temu not solely routinely steal product images that are used to mislead prospects into considering they’re getting the unique, superior product, however they steal the designs and manufacture them too.
The defence I’ve usually heard is that folks can’t afford to buy elsewhere. All of us managed to manage earlier than with out Temu, Want and so forth. so what has instantly modified? It’s a very lame excuse.
Advertising and marketing is designed to place merchandise in entrance of your eyes and to maintain placing them there in order that they keep in your head. It’s designed to make you’re feeling good, to present you heat fuzzy emotions and optimistic associations which persuade you into shopping for, even when it’s one thing you don’t actually need, or one thing you solely need fleetingly.
“Store like a thieving pound store povo” can be a extra becoming tagline for Temu.
The much-used tagline of “Store like a billionaire” is weird within the excessive. I’m sure that billionaires would haven’t any must trawl by way of a poorly designed migraine of an internet site to purchase 89p novelty earrings that flip your ears inexperienced or a poorly printed, badly becoming t-shirt for £5.39.
I believe maybe “Store like a thieving pound store povo” can be a extra becoming tagline for Temu.
The truth that folks will obtain an app like that is astonishing. Ask your self why a retailer would actually need an app. What can an app do {that a} web site can’t do? The reply is clear. It’s your information they need.
While you obtain the Temu app, you’re granting entry to far more of your private information than a retail web site is legally allowed to gather. For a corporation whose HQ is in China, if that’s not a priority to you, it actually must be.
I completely perceive utilizing websites like these in some circumstances. Let’s say you want an affordable fancy costume outfit, a prop for a celebration you may’t discover anyplace else, however aside from that, how about we purchase much less crap and pay a good worth for the issues we do purchase?
Dupe tradition legitimises stealing
The entire ‘dupe’ tradition which is rampant on TikTok is a superb instance of normalising ripping off designers. From Teva to Dr Martens, impartial marriage ceremony costume designers to illustrators, numerous merchandise are being ‘duped’ and people dupes aren’t solely overtly talked about, however celebrated.
The dictionary definition of a dupe is “an unscrupulous deception”, for even much less flattering definitions, take a look at what Merriam-Webster has to say.
Completely nothing related to the phrase is optimistic, but the seemingly innocent, fluffy world of ‘dupes’ is being celebrated, with influencers too grasping to care and wannabe influencers too silly to care, proudly displaying off their hauls.
Let’s not faux that these ‘chunky gladiator-style sandals with yellow stitching’ designed to look precisely the identical as a widely known model, however at afraction of the worth is something however a replica, a faux.
Meaning all the design and R&D course of invested in by the unique creator has been copied and reinvented, utilizing cheaper supplies.
Copying stuff is stealing, so right here’s a radical concept. Should you can’t afford to spend £120 on a pair of Dr Martens Blaire sandals, purchase one thing else as a substitute.
The faux mentality
With clothes, footwear and trend equipment in thoughts, I can solely assume that Temu customers and people which might be clamouring to snap up ‘dupes’ on TikTok outlets are the kind of those that go on vacation to Turkey and return house dripping in faux designer watches and luggage.
You’re shopping for a stolen, copied product which suggests the unique creator is dropping out.
Should you can’t afford one thing, why would you wish to faux that you would be able to? It doesn’t make you look cool or trendy or wealthy. It makes you appear to be an egotistical, insecure fool.
So let’s please cease making out that ‘dupes’ are an amazing deal and an harmless means of getting one thing you need. They aren’t. You’re shopping for a stolen, copied product which suggests the unique creator is dropping out.
Temu & dupes are killing livelihoods
As a hand-crafted enterprise proprietor, I do know firsthand that the work that goes into creating merchandise is immense. Many artists, handmade and small companies don’t have even a fraction of the promoting funds that the likes of Temu have at their disposal. They dedicate numerous hours dreaming up, designing and making their merchandise, then much more time attempting to get seen organically to allow them to generate, usually modest, gross sales.
Then alongside comes a China-based producer who takes a take a look at what’s out there in locations like Etsy and any intelligent or cool designs, they merely steal and manufacture at a fraction of the fee.
Not solely does this massively undercut the unique creator, it additionally devalues their unique work.
That dragon crochet hat that took per week to make from an unique sample and retails for a few hundred kilos in consequence, will get copied and is now being bought elsewhere for £24.99.
These layered acrylic hair claws bought at a really affordable £18.99, that began as an concept, then sketches, then a digital file that was then lower on an costly laser machine that’s not even near being paid off after which assembled, photographed and listed…now out there on AliExpress for £3.99. All of that work shouldn’t be solely stolen, however irrevocably devalued immediately.
I don’t assume it’s the case that folks simply basically don’t care. After all there’ll at all times be some that don’t, however I believe on the entire, folks simply don’t cease to assume. Lured by low cost costs and the fixed promise of one thing new and higher that fuels this capitalist nightmare we discover ourselves in.
It’s simpler to simply click on the purchase button than it’s to cease and ponder the ethics of what your buying choice actually means.
That ‘dupe’ shouldn’t be innocent. That cute felt hat on Temu that appears identical to one thing you noticed on Etsy that was far more costly, shouldn’t be a discount. It’s killing the artists and creators that invested a lot of their time and creativity into making the unique.
While most creators are powerless to cease their designs being copied, shoppers completely have the ability to make an moral choice.
The longer this theft continues unchecked, the tougher will probably be for handmade companies and artists to proceed scraping a residing while big producers like PDD Holdings Inc. who personal Temu, proceed to make thousands and thousands, dodging taxes by way of loopholes and function with immunity to Mental Property legal guidelines.
Learn the miserable fact of why It’s Completely Authorized for Your Chinese language Producer to Copy Your Merchandise.
Suppose before you purchase
So please, earlier than you click on the purchase button, cease for a second to think about whose livelihood you may be destroying in your pursuit of what you understand to be a discount.
Should you see one thing on a web based market like Temu that appears to be considerably cheaper than you’d anticipate, or it’s much like one thing you’ve seen elsewhere, it may very well be that the design has been stolen. Each sale of that product given to the likes of Temu is instantly and adversely impacting the very actual individual, or those that initially created it.
Your Temu or harmless seeming TikTok ‘dupe’ buying choice has very actual, generally devastating penalties.
References